CONTACT
(941) 877-5588

×

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

The Gulf Coast’s culinary scene is as vibrant and diverse as its landscape, offering everything from upscale dining to laid-back waterfront shacks. For those looking to dive deep into the local flavors and experience the true essence of dining, here are five must-visit gulf coast restaurants that promise an unforgettable meal.

 

1. Indigenous (Sarasota)

For a sophisticated yet approachable dining experience, Indigenous stands out with its commitment to sustainable, seasonal American cuisine. Located in Sarasota, this acclaimed restaurant prides itself on a menu that evolves with the availability of peak ingredients, sourced directly from local fishermen, artisans, and farmers. Their strong focus on sustainable seafood not only ensures the highest quality but also contributes to a better food system. Indigenous offers an intimate setting where thoughtful dishes and a passion for fresh, local ingredients shine.

 

2. Owen’s Fish Camp (Downtown Sarasota & Lakewood Ranch)

Step back in time to “Old Florida living” at Owen’s Fish Camp, a beloved Southern Seafood restaurant with locations in Downtown Sarasota and Lakewood Ranch. This charming spot serves up fresh, local seafood daily alongside classic Southern dishes and a great selection of craft beers and wines. The Downtown Sarasota location, nestled within an old Florida house, boasts a historic Banyan tree (a gift from Thomas Edison to Sarasota developer Owen Burns) and a tire swing, creating a casual, hospitable atmosphere. It’s the perfect place to enjoy delicious food steeped in local history.

 

3. New Pass Grill & Bait Shop (Sarasota Bay)

Experience a true Sarasota landmark since 1929 at New Pass Grill & Bait Shop. This unique spot offers an authentic “old Florida atmosphere” right on Sarasota Bay. Famous for its “world-class burgers” and the “coldest beer on the water,” their extensive menu also includes fresh grouper sandwiches and local breakfast favorites. But it’s more than just a grill; it’s a one-stop shop for fishing enthusiasts, with a bait shop that’s been “baitin’ hooks for almost 100 years” and options for fishing charters. It’s an iconic spot for a meal with a view and a touch of local adventure.

 

4. The Star Fish Company Market & Restaurant (Cortez)

For the freshest catch straight from the Gulf, head to The Star Fish Company Market & Restaurant in Cortez, one of Florida’s last remaining working fishing villages. This dockside eatery offers a no-frills, authentic experience where the focus is simply on delicious, locally caught seafood prepared grilled, sautéed, or fried. With direct sourcing from their own market, you’re guaranteed unparalleled freshness. Enjoy your meal with stunning, relaxed views of Sarasota Bay, making it a local favorite for good food and picturesque scenery.

 

5. Blue Marlin Seafood (Bradenton Beach, Anna Maria Island)

Just a short drive to Bradenton Beach on Anna Maria Island, Blue Marlin Seafood offers an intimate and charming dining experience in a 90-year-old nautical chic cottage. This restaurant is celebrated for its incredible coastal cuisine, with seafood sourced fresh from Cortez. Beyond the delectable dishes like their famous Lobster Grilled Cheese and Cortez Chowder, Blue Marlin provides a cozy atmosphere, live music on weekends, and an expertly curated selection of cocktails and wines. Reservations are highly recommended due to its intimate size, ensuring a delightful evening that feels like visiting a friend’s beach house.

From farm-to-table excellence to rustic fishing village charm, these gulf coast restaurants offer more than just food—they provide a genuine taste of the region’s unique culture and bounty. Enjoy your culinary journey!

Need a morning pick me up, check out these local coffee shops.

 

Sarasota, Florida, is renowned for its stunning beaches and vibrant arts scene, but did you know it also boasts a thriving coffee culture? Beyond the bustling tourist spots, a collection of charming and unique coffee houses has captured the hearts of locals. Whether you’re a connoisseur seeking a perfectly brewed single-origin or simply looking for a cozy spot to enjoy a morning pastry, Sarasota’s coffee scene has something for everyone.

Join us on a tour of some of Sarasota’s most beloved coffee havens, where you can savor delicious drinks and soak in the local flavor.

1. Mojo Risin Coffee Co. (Siesta Key)

Nestled on Siesta Key, Mojo Risin Coffee Co. is a true island gem. Hailed by locals as Siesta Key’s “BEST Coffee,” this spot offers a laid-back vibe perfect for a pre-beach caffeine boost or a relaxing afternoon. Beyond their acclaimed coffee, you can explore their shop for merchandise or even grab a gift card for a fellow coffee lover. It’s the quintessential Siesta Key coffee experience.

2. Palma Coffee Co. (Sarasota)

For those who appreciate the journey from bean to cup, Palma Coffee Co. is a must-visit. This Sarasota-based company is driven by a passion for ethically sourced, high-quality coffee. They directly partner with environmentally responsible producers, bringing unique single-origin whole bean coffees like Pink Bourbon from Finca Bet-el and organic varieties from Chiapas, Mexico, and Marcala, Honduras, right to your mug. They even offer intriguing Cascara Tea, made from coffee cherries! Palma Coffee Co. is a testament to the power of coffee to connect communities, from its origin to your hometown.

3. The Clever Cup Coffee Shop (Sarasota)

Since 2016, The Clever Cup Coffee Shop has been a vibrant hub in Sarasota, earning the well-deserved title of “Best Coffee Shop of 2019” from Sarasota Magazine. This welcoming space prides itself on serving organic, locally roasted, and fair-trade coffee and tea from Black Gold Coffee Roasters. Beyond their handcrafted beverages, you’ll find an array of organic teas, delicious pastries, and an impressive selection of vegan-friendly options. The Clever Cup is more than just a coffee shop; it’s a community gathering spot, often hosting live music events that add to its warm and inviting atmosphere.

4. Breaking Wave Coffee (Downtown Sarasota)

Bringing a touch of Australian and New Zealand coffee culture to downtown Sarasota, Breaking Wave Coffee is an independently owned cafe and espresso bar dedicated to exceptional service and top-tier drinks. Opened in 2019, it has quickly become a standout in the local specialty coffee scene, just a stone’s throw from Marina Jack. Whether you’re popping in for a quick grab-and-go or seeking a full cafe experience, Breaking Wave offers an efficient and friendly service that keeps locals coming back for their unique coffee offerings. They even have a mobile coffee cart available for catering special events!

5. Meaney’s Mini Donuts (Siesta Key Village)

While technically not a coffee house, Meaney’s Mini Donuts is an absolute essential stop for any coffee lover in Sarasota, as coffee and donuts are a match made in heaven! Featured as an Editor’s Pick in Sarasota Magazine, this walk-up window in Siesta Key Village serves up light, almost beignet-like mini-doughnuts made fresh right before your eyes. Choose your favorite coating for these addictive treats – the strawberry cheesecake, with its cream cheese frosting and strawberry jam, comes highly recommended. It’s the perfect sweet companion to your morning brew.

We hope this guide helps you discover your new favorite local coffee spot in Sarasota! Enjoy your sips!

When you’re ready to cast your line around Siesta Key, finding the right charter can make all the difference. This guide to Siesta Key fishing charter recommendations covers the best inshore and offshore fishing charters, as well as top-rated water activities like dolphin watching and sunset cruises—perfect for every kind of vacationer.

 

Inshore & Nearshore Siesta Key Fishing Charters

Inshore fishing around Siesta Key is ideal for beginners, families, and those seeking a relaxed day on calm waters. Expect to catch snook, redfish, trout, and more while cruising mangrove-lined shores and protected bays.

Inshore/Nearshore Charter Options:

  • Chasin’ Tail with Captain Tyler
    Specializing in light-tackle inshore and nearshore fishing, Captain Tyler customizes trips for families and avid anglers alike. He’s known for his patience with kids and deep local knowledge.
    Book Chasin’ Tail
  • Siesta Key Fishing Charters
    Highly rated for family-friendly trips, they customize your experience and are praised for their knowledgeable captains and excellent service. All ages and experience levels are welcome.
    Book Siesta Key Fishing Charters
  • Reel Tight Fishing Charters
    Captain Brian Martel offers inshore and nearshore trips, targeting redfish, trout, and more. All gear, bait, and licensing provided.
    Book Reel Tight Fishing Charters

Offshore & Deep Sea Siesta Key Fishing Charters

For the adventurous, offshore deep-sea charters take you beyond the shoreline to target larger game fish like tuna, grouper, amberjack, mahi-mahi, and even sailfish.

Offshore Charter Options:

  • Seafood Charters
    Family-owned and specializing in deep-sea fishing, Seafood Charters targets tuna, amberjack, grouper, and more. They’re known for a friendly, fun atmosphere.
    Book Seafood Charters
  • Siesta Key Sport Fishing Charters
    Captain Damian takes you out on a 30’ Carolina Classic for offshore action. Target blackfin tuna, king mackerel, grouper, snapper, and more. Child-friendly and accessible.
    Book Siesta Key Sport Fishing Charters
  • Blue Line Fishing Charters
    Highly rated for offshore trips, Blue Line targets pelagic species and provides all gear, bait, and licensing.
    Book Blue Line Fishing Charters

If Fishing Isn’t Your Thing…

There’s plenty to enjoy on the Gulf even if you don’t want to fish! Siesta Key is famous for its sunset cruises and dolphin-watching tours. Here are two excellent alternatives to Lucky 13 Charters:

Top Water Activities Besides Fishing:

  • Fun Boat Tours
    Offers daily dolphin tours, sandbar trips, sunset cruises, and private custom charters departing from Siesta Key Marina. Their sunset cruises feature music and a lively, family-friendly atmosphere.
    Book Fun Boat Tours
  • Siesta Dolphin Tours
    Provides morning mimosa cruises, sunset/dolphin cruises, sandbar dolphin cruises, and more. Boats are comfortable with shade and bathrooms, accommodating up to 30 guests—great for families and groups.
    Book Siesta Dolphin Tours
  • Sarasota Bay Explorers
    Known for narrated sunset and dolphin cruises, offering BYOB options and a fun, educational experience.
    Book Sarasota Bay Explorers

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About Siesta Key Fishing Charters

What should I bring on a fishing charter in Siesta Key?
Most charters provide all fishing gear, bait, and licenses. Bring sunscreen, sunglasses, a hat, snacks, drinks, and a camera. Wear comfortable, weather-appropriate clothing and non-slip shoes.

When is the best time of year to fish in Siesta Key?
Spring and fall are ideal for inshore species like snook and redfish. Summer and early fall are best for offshore catches such as grouper and snapper. Tarpon season peaks in late spring and early summer.

Are fishing licenses required for charters?
No, reputable charters include the necessary fishing licenses for all guests.

Can kids join fishing charters?
Absolutely! Many charters are family-friendly and offer trips suitable for children of all ages.

What happens if the weather is bad?
Safety is the top priority. If weather conditions are unsafe, charters will reschedule or refund your trip.

Are there other things to do besides fishing?
Yes! Siesta Key offers dolphin tours, sunset cruises, sandbar trips, and more. For more ideas, check out our vacation rentals and activity guide.

Handy Tips Before You Go

  • All charters provide rods, reels, tackle, and handle your fishing license.
  • Pricing ranges from about $300 for half-day inshore trips to $1,200+ for full-day offshore adventures.
  • Book early—Siesta Key charters are in high demand, especially during peak season.

 

If you’re searching for the best Siesta Key fishing charter recommendations, top names like Chasin’ Tail, Siesta Key Fishing Charters, and Seafood Charters offer unforgettable experiences for every type of angler. And if casting a line isn’t your thing, sunset and dolphin cruises with companies like Fun Boat Tours and Siesta Dolphin Tours deliver all the coastal magic without the bait. Book your adventure now and experience the best of Florida’s Gulf Coast!

When compiling a list of the best beach towns, the omission of Sanibel Island would be truly incomplete. We wholeheartedly agree with Southern Living for recognizing the undeniable allure of this exceptional destination, ranking it proudly at No. 6 in their esteemed “The 50 Best Beach Towns in the South 2025” list. This prestigious recognition also positions Sanibel as the top-rated Florida beach town on their list, a testament to its enduring appeal.

Southern Living acknowledged the ongoing recovery of Sanibel Island following the impact of Hurricane Ian in September 2022, as well as Hurricanes Milton and Helene in 2024.

Despite these challenges, Southern Living beautifully captured the spirit of Sanibel, stating:

A sunny slice of paradise that’s as resilient as they come, Sanibel was struck by three hurricanes (Ian, Helene, and Milton) in the span of just over two years, but it continues to persevere. With no stoplights or high-rises, the island is an old-school beach town at its best. Once you’ve come here, it won’t be long before you’ve adopted the Sanibel stoop, the well-known posture of serious shell seekers.

Indeed, as many who have visited will attest, Sanibel Island possesses a captivating charm that often steals hearts unexpectedly. The scenic drive over the causeway unveils a breathtaking panorama: 17,000 acres of lush natural beauty bordered by the sparkling Gulf of Mexico on one side and the tranquil San Carlos Bay on the other.

Stepping onto Sanibel, you’ll immediately sense a departure from the hustle and bustle of nearby cities like Tampa and Fort Myers. The absence of stoplights, high-rises, and sprawling chain stores contributes to an atmosphere of serene tranquility. This unique character fosters a strong sense of community, local pride, and an appreciation for the island’s remarkable natural treasures.

sanibel island family fun - gulf coast vacation rentals

Southern Living further highlights the “9 Best things to do in Sanibel Island,” which includes the beloved pastime of searching for shells, along with opportunities for walking and biking along scenic wildlife trails, and a delightful selection of places to eat and stay.

It’s wonderful to see other gems on the Gulf Coast recognized as well, with Naples ranking at No. 22 and Captiva Island, Sanibel’s close neighbor, securing the No. 25 spot, Siesta Key comes in at 15, and authentic Anna Maria Island finishes at 11.

The No. 1 best beach town in the South, according to Southern Living, is St. Simons Island, Georgia, praised for its alluring atmosphere, delicious shrimp, stunning sunsets, and a wealth of activities ranging from wildlife viewing and sailing to biking and exploring historical landmarks.

However, for those seeking an authentic beach town experience renowned for its natural beauty and world-class shelling, Sanibel Island remains an unparalleled destination. We invite you to discover the magic of Sanibel firsthand by staying at one of our many vacation rentals. From condos to pool homes, beachfront stays, and pet-friendly getaways we have every option available.

To read Southern Livings full list of the 50 Beast Beach Towns In The South, click here.

×